Skip to content

Build it yourself,
or pay someone?

If you are brand new, testing whether the business works, or you genuinely have more time than money, build it yourself. A Wix or Squarespace site you finish this weekend beats a perfect site you never commission. Pay someone once the website has a job to do — when you need it to generate enquiries rather than just exist, and when the hours it takes you are worth more on the tools.

Side by side

  Do it yourself Pay someone
Cash cost Roughly $20–$50 a month. Genuinely cheap. $1,000–$20,000 upfront depending on scope.
Time cost Realistically 20–60 hours for a first site, spread over evenings. A few hours of your input. The rest is on us.
How it looks Templates are good now. It will look fine. Built around your business rather than a template.
Local SEO structure The real weakness. Building a page per service and per suburb is possible but fiddly, and most DIY sites never do it. The whole point. Structure is designed around the searches you want.
Converting visitors Templates are designed to look good, not to generate quote requests. Built to produce enquiries, which is a different discipline from design.
Changing it later Instant, and free. A genuine advantage. Depends on the arrangement. Ask before you commit.
Who owns it You are renting the platform. Leaving usually means rebuilding. You own the code and content outright.

Do it yourself when

  • You are brand new and still finding out whether the business works.
  • Nearly all your work comes from referral and the site is just somewhere to point people.
  • Cash is tight. A DIY site now beats an agency site in six months.
  • You enjoy it, or want to understand how it fits together before paying for one.
  • You need something live this week.

Pay someone when

  • You want the phone to ring because of the website, not despite it.
  • You are competing for searches where other businesses are actively investing.
  • Your time is worth more on the tools. Forty hours of evenings is a week of work you did not do.
  • You need a page per service and per suburb, done properly, which is where DIY sites usually stall.
  • You have tried DIY and it is not producing enquiries.

Our honest take

The honest test is what you want the website to do. If it needs to exist so you look legitimate when someone Googles your name after a referral, build it yourself — you will do a perfectly good job and spending thousands would be a waste. If it needs to bring in work you would not otherwise have got, that is a different discipline: structure, local search, and conversion, none of which templates do for you. Most trade businesses start with the first and move to the second when referrals stop covering the diary.

Common questions

Is Wix or Squarespace bad for SEO?
Not inherently. Both handle the basics competently now. The limitation is structural: real local SEO needs a genuine page for each service and each area, properly linked, and that is tedious enough on a DIY builder that almost nobody does it. The platform is not what holds you back — the effort is.
How long does a DIY site take?
Plan on 20 to 60 hours for a first one, spread over evenings and weekends. Most people underestimate the writing rather than the building. Deciding what each page should say is the slow part.
Can you fix a site I built myself?
Often, yes, and it is usually cheaper than starting again. Sometimes the platform is the limitation and a rebuild is more honest. We will tell you which — run it through the free website check first and you will have a good idea before you call.
What if I start DIY and outgrow it?
That is a completely normal path and not a wasted effort. You will know far better what you need second time around, and your content usually comes across. Just register the domain in your own name from day one so it moves with you.
If I decide to pay someone, should it be a freelancer or an agency?
That is the next question once you have ruled out DIY, and it is a genuine trade-off rather than an obvious answer — see freelancer versus agency for the honest version, including where we fit.
Also worth reading: WordPress vs Custom-built Also worth reading: Google Ads vs Local SEO Also worth reading: Wix / Squarespace vs Purpose-built Also worth reading: A $500 website vs A $1,000 website Also worth reading: Shopify vs WooCommerce Also worth reading: A freelancer vs An agency

Still not sure?

Tell us what you are trying to achieve and we will tell you which way we would go — including if that is not with us.

Prefer to talk? Call 08 6323 2970

How many staff in your business? *
I'm interested in...

No spam. We’ll respond within 1 business day.

Call 08 6323 2970 Quote